Documented Life     Ancestors - Troper and Hochstein Genealogies

Ancestors of Miles Hochstein (Grandfather)

G. Day Smith

(b. May 9, 1882 in Mitchell, South Dakota,
d. September 10, 1946 in Kansas City, Missouri)

"He had a mild sense of humor." Gianna Smith Hochstein, his daughter, 2001)

"He was an avid gardener, especially growing scented flowers." Bertha Smith, his wife, 1950s

" 'Whiz' Smith found his greatest delight in journalism in the careful editing of copy. He preferred to sit quietly editing rephrasing smoothing and searching for the precise words to make the stories he was to present to the reader as concise as possible. Gentle and soft-spoken Mr. Smith never raised his voice as he subtly suggested to reporters revisions in their copy which would improve a story." Star Obituary, 1946.

"He was a teetotaler among hard drinking newspapermen, and a Democrat at a Republican newspaper, and so he never really fit in at work." (Gianna Hochstein, his daughter, 2000)

Occupation: Newspaperman (Assistant Sunday Editor, 1920-1946, Kansas City Star)

Son of Emma Kate (Day) Smith and Jacob K. Smith, and raised primarily by his adoptive parents, "Aunt Me (aka Marrium) and Uncle John."

Husband of Bertha (Schmidt) Smith.

Father of Gianna (Smith) Hochstein (b. 1926) and Marium Rowena (1921-1967) and one child who died in infancy.

Grandfather of Terry Longstreth, Janice Longstreth McClintock, Miles Hochstein, and Evon Hochstein.

Great-grandfather of seven.

Above: Aunt Marrium and Uncle John (so labeled on back of photo) of Eldora Iowa, G. Day Smith's foster parents. Thanks to N.S. (see bottom of this page) the mystery of their identity and relationship to G. Day Smith appears to be resolved. Marrium (nee Stevens) Porter and Judge John Porter are their names, and it seems likely that Marrium (nee Stevens) Porter was the sister of Marilla Stevens, who was G.Day Smith's maternal grandmother. In other word Day was sent to Eldora, his father Jacob Smith's home town to be raised by his maternal great-aunt, when his mother Emma Day Smith died in 1884.

Day became a "college boy" (attending Grinnell College, in Iowa, which my mother would later graduate), but he spent the summers (or more) as a mule skinner (mule train driver) in South Dakota.

There are pictures of him taken in Mitchell, South Dakota and in Eldora Iowa at multiple ages, so presumably he visited his father Jacob K. Smith in South Dakota with some regularity.

In order to get into Grinnell college he had to spend an additional year (circa 1903) taking High School courses in Kansas City while living with the family of his deceased mother's brother, George Willard Day (see photo much further below).

 

George Day Smith was born in Mitchell, South Dakota, and raised in Eldora Iowa. He was known by the first name of "Day", after his mother's family.

My mother, Gianna, reports that he said that he was lovingly raised by an aunt ("Aunt Me", apparently for Marrium) and her husband, "although it wasn't the same as having his own mother." He would name his eldest daughter Marrium, presumably after the woman who raised him.

When Day's mother Emma Day died at the age of 2, he was sent by his father Jacob K. Smith to be raised by his aunt Marrium in Eldora, Hardin County, Iowa, the hometown of his father Jacob Smith.

Marrium (nee Stevens) Porter, it appears, was his great-aunt (sister of his maternal grandmother.) Her husband was Judge John Porter.

Left, Above and Below: G. Day Smith as a child in Mitchell South Dakota and Eldora Iowa

Above: Inscription on back of photo above "George Day Smith, my cousin - (from Helen Day Evans, I think)"

Above: Iowa boys with attitude - Young men hanging out. - G.Day Smith is left and center in pictures above.

Above: Could this have been the home of G. Day Smith's adoptive parents, "Aunt Me and Uncle John" in Eldora, Iowa? I'm researching this possibility.

 

Above: Grinnell College pals, class of 1907 with G. Day Smith, far right.

G. Day Smith Wrote a Memorable (but Forgotten) Poem in Those Years

March 12, 2007,

Dear Miles,

Following a Grinnell reunion in Washington, D.C., I met a fellow Grinnellian on our trolley ride homeward. When I sat down next to a smiling grey-haired lady she told me that she had known my father at Grinnell. This remarkable old woman (in 1956 she would have been about 70 - not so old to me at 81 today) then recited a poem that my father had written in those years form 1904 to 1907. Regrettably, my research in the basement archives of the library failed to reveal any poem that my father had published. Nor can I remember much about either the poem or the lady's name; both were from what my father referred to as the "oughts" (as in "class of ought seven").

Love, Gianna

 

 

Day graduated from Grinnell College in 1907.

Above: Ice skating

Right: How you dress for tennis in the 1900s.

Above: From a series of photos with Grinnell college friends, 1904-1907, most likely around 1907.

Home Sweet Home (below)

Above: "Dining room at Eyra's in Eldora. 'My Bessie' took this hense she isn't in it. Your place is between Jim and Frank." So reads the inscription on the back, suggesting that this is Day's (adoptive) family in Eldora Iowa, "Aunt Marriam and Uncle John".  I believe that Marrium "Aunt Mea" is fifth from left, and her husband "Uncle John" is 2nd from left. Some of the same faces are recognizable below, but somewhat older.

Above and Below: Family Photos with G. Day Smith in Eldora, Iowa, circa 1900-1910

Left to Right, back row, Two unknown persons (Perhaps son-in-law and daughter of Marrium and John?), and Aunt Marrium (aka Aunt Me). Left to right, front row, G. Day Smith reclining, "Uncle John"?, and perhaps John's brother or father? Same gentleman appears in a few other pictures with the family.

Day told the genealogist Adele Andrews in or before 1940 that at various times he and Bertha had lived in Iowa, Missouri and Minnesota. If the story about Chicago is correct, presumably he also lived in Illinois.

In a letter to Gianna (K.C. Mo., 11-20-55) his wife Bertha Smith wrote:

"There is a a mistake about the part concerning me. I never lived either in Iowa or Minnesota. Your dad lived in Eldora, IA, from the time he was 2 until 18, K.C. [Kansas City?] at Uncle George's one year taking on extra work in H.S.; then in Grinnell [where he attended college]; for a short time in Des Moines, working on the Register & Leader; then Hannibal for two years; Duluth, two years; Chicago with the Associated Press for a short time, Jefferson City with the A.P. and Seattle."

 


Right, GD Smith in a crowd. I have a larger version of this photo. I believe that this would be a college photo, and not from Eldora. Date? Probably circa 1905-1908. Do the clothes or hat styles provide any clues to dating?

When I asked my mother what "essential truth" I should know about her father she replied "He had a mild sense of humor."

Right: Woman on horseback. Day collected many pictures of young women, all unlabeled. This is one of the most romantic of them. I read them as "souvenirs" of his younger days when he had yet to find a wife.

Above and below: G. Day Smith, circa 1907 -1917, possibly in Mitchell, South Dakota, probably when he was working as a mule skinner in South Dakota. Since the picture above left appears in his 1917 class letters book, this series cannot be from later than 1917.

Above: 1917 at the latest

Above: 1917 at the latest

My mother estimated that the four pictures above (and at top of page) are from his mule skinner days, around 1905-1907, in his mid-twenties, when after college he lived in South Dakota. However in fact he did not graduate college until 1907, so these pictures are more likely from between 1907 and the year 1917, when one of them appears in his 1917 class letters booklet.

Above and below: Unlabeled and undated scenes from the photographs of G.D.Smith. Could the photos above and below be from Mitchell, South Dakota, around 1910? My sources in Mitchell, South Dakota think not, and so, these photos are probably best labled simply "scenes from the midwestern and western landscape" through which G. Day Smith travelled in his days as a journalist. I find these photos to be mind boggling. To think that my grandfather walked the streets of towns that looked like that!

According to the Andrews genalogy (1940) Day's career in journalism began at least as early as 5 years after his 1907 graduation from Grinnel.

"He has been a journalist, with the Kansas City Star since 1912." (p. 41)

It probably began even before that. As we can see below, he is a merry writer in 1914, at the age of 32.


Below: G.Day Smith reports back to the Grinnell College Class of 1907 in the June, 1914 "Annual class Letter of Grinnell college", at age 32.

G. Day Says To the Editor: "Be Sure To Add Postscript"

Kansas City, March 26, 1914:-- Dear Nineteen-Seveners: after several days of looking Ariel and I have decided that it shall be one of those Orioloe go-baskets that will make him look like a little papoose. By him of course I mean our boy who is still too young to receive a name, although several are under consideration for him. It might be well to explain here, everything in the order of its importance, that Ariel and I were married last year a little after I was supposed to write my class letter and didn't. Ariel is a Kansas City girl I met about two years ago, but our partnership agreement was reached rather suddenly and the ceremony was the shortest we could find. We have a little cottage, some roses and room for an onion patch, an Irish terrier and a canary bird in addition to "the boy."

It might be news to some of the class also to know that I have left the newspaper business and that as secretary of an aviation company I expect to be the "advance man" for our entry in the around-the-globe air race from Frisco next year. My wife objected to my flying so I rarely go up in the air now, except figuratively. Maybe on my trips I will get to see some of you, but I certainly hope none of you will come to Kansas City without looking me up. With best regards for all, I remain, strange to say.

G. Day Smith, '07

P.S. This being the kind of a class letter I would like to have write, why this was the letter I wrote. It is my opinion that the class of 1907 has given the world no genius that has anything on me as a liar. G.D.S.


Below. A relatively young Day with pipe and friends, in front of cabin, date and
location unknown. I speculate that this might be Day as a young journalist.

At one point he was employed in journalism in Chicago, but lost that job under circumstances that were unpleasant, but are unknown.

A few documents in his effects attest to the fact that Day attempted to enlist in the army during the Great War. He was not able to do so due to a health problem of some kind.

Considering that America's involvement and opportunities to enlist came late in the war (circa 1916?) he would have been almost 34, and surely a bit old for military service.

And so, not for lack of trying, Day survived the Great War and lived to marry and produce two daughters, Marrium (Swish) and my mother Gianna.

But before he married Bertha in 1920 (age 38), he joked in 1917 (age 35) to his 1907 Grinnell classmates about fatherhood as follows.

In the letter that follows, in the midst of the Great War he continues to strike a jolly note, but also is slightly melancholy with a line such as "...all my young heart cries out for."

 

Below: A class letter, written in 1917 by G.Day Smith, when residing at 2812 East Sixth St., Kansas City, Mo.

Kansas City, Mo. April Fool, 1917 (Hold for release in June)

Welcome back to the campus, 1917, greeting and handshakes!

After our brief absence from the halls of learning, as 'twer, but that reminds me: What is this report prevalent in certain quarters, even of our class, that 1907 has been out of school ten years, that it has been a decade since I rented a black robe and paraded with the rest of you down the aisle of the Congregational church into pews roped off with scarlet and white ribbons?

Absurd! Preposterous! Faugh! Three Ha's in a row. I have even the matter some attention and after figuring carefully, calling to my assistance all of the mathematical knowledge I can recall from my courses in trig and surveying, I am able to announce posolutely that our diplomas were passed out just one year ago. This I suppose accounts for the figure one that has appeared before the seven in some of the recent calendars.

Here is the correct dope:

After graduation I was in Des Moines about a month on the Register and Leader, then a month here in Kansas City on the Post. Next I was city, country, society, police, musical, railroad, motor, movie and dramatic editor of the Hannibal Courier Post for about a month. That's three months. Then I went to the Duluth News Tribune for, say, about two months and from there came here again where I have been seven months on the Star. Three months, plus two months, plus seven months, equals twelve months and none to carry, equal one year. Quod erat demonstrandum. (Note how the Latin quotations leap to my li-, typewriter.)

As further evidence that we graduated just a year ago, I call attention to the fact that I feel exactly one year younger although I modestly admit that I appear almost ten years younger. This estimate is made after making due allowance for the physical improvement naturally following when I was relieved of the severe strain of studying, attending Annual Board function, cutting chapel and fussing.

As proof that I am looking younger, I am sending two specially posed kodak views, one of my present aspect and the other taken when I was in college. I know only one was asked or expected but there was no assurance even that would be printed and the worst that can happen to these "Before and After" pictures will be for them to be thrown away. And that will have no effect whatever on my grand and glorious feeling of youth that may be likened to that of the spring lamb.

I summon all of you to take steps to correct these misstatements about 1907 having been graduated ten years ago. Why, by and by, they will be saying it was fifteen or twenty years ago. The best way to contradict it is for every one of us to come back to each commencement. No class that has been out of school fifteen or twenty years ever had a full attendance at Commencement and the enemy's logic will be confounded. No class that has been out ten years ever bore down under full pressure on "I'm Goin' to be '07 Until I die".

And that's the melody that all my young being cries out for.

G. Day Smith (1917)

 

Above: Courting Time - Day skating with unknown woman, date unknown. I would guess that it is taken between his college graduation in 1907 and his marriage in 1920.

After an extended courtship by US mail, lasting many years (source, Gianna Hochstein), Day moved to Kansas City to marry my grandmother, Bertha (Schmidt) Smith, on June 19, 1920 in Hannibal MO, at the age of 38. Like him she was a journalist. She would have been 39 years old.

Gianna told me that they delayed marriage for a long time because it was not possible to consider marriage until he made $50/week. This, they agreed, was the minimum that would make it possible for him to sustain a family. When he got the job at the Star, and only then, marriage was possible. So his marriage to his Bertha and to the Star were parallel and intertwined and he continued with both until his death in 1946.

Old Legal Documents

Evidence of their efforts to purchase a house following their marriage in 1920 comes from some old legal documents in Gianna's possession. On September 18, 1922, George W. Day (Attorney and Counselor at Law, New York Life Building, Kansas City, Mo.) sent a letter to Mr. and Mrs. G. Day Smith rendering his opinion about the "abstract of title" for the purchase of a property in Kansas City. He seems to advise them against it for various reasons involving unresolved leins and debts. I mention this only because attorney George W. Day is presumably George Willard Day (December 22, 1856 - January 25, 1927) the brother of G. Day Smith's biological mother, Emma Kate Day.

George Willard Day married Emma Worden on July 17, 1889 in Cleveland, and had one child of which I am aware, Helen Day in 1890 (named presumably after George Willard Day's sister Helen (Day) Kibee(?). Helen Day bore Barbara Evans (1921) Dorothy Evans (1925). There my own records currently end.

Since I've seen a number of references to "Uncle George" in Kansas City with whom G. Day Smith went to stay with around 1902 or 1903, to take additional high school work before going to Grinnell College. It seems likely that this is the Uncle George to which they referred.

Above: Day's uncle, George Willard Day (b. 1853), brother of his biological mother Emma Kate (Day) Smith.

Above: 1929 - Day at age 47, family man. The only picture that I have seen of all four family members in one photograph, G. Day Smith, Bertha Smith, my mother Gianna Smith (about age 3) and my aunt Marrium Smith (about age 8). The photo is labeled "At Unity Farm" on front, and "Taken Labor Day, 1929 - As you see, this is over 2 yr. old. It is a picture of my family and me." This was probably written by Marrium. There was an "X" marked on Marrium's image that I have partially removed. My mother Gianna is on the left.

 

Day in the 1930s or 1940s. This is the portrait that appears in pen and ink in his Kansas City Star obituary as well.

The inscription on the photo above reads: "George Day Smith, ca 1940. He was an avid gardener, especially growing scented flowers." On the front of the picture above, at the bottom, it says "Dad in work clothes."


Day was a newspaperman, a Democrat at what my mother thinks was a Republican leaning paper, the "Kansas City Star." He joined the newspaper in 1912 at the age of 30.

More importantly, perhaps, he was a teetotaler among hard drinking newspapermen, and so, my mother says, he never quite fit in at the newspaper.

Day was a Roosevelt Democrat, and his wife, my grandmother Bertha, was a Hoover supporter. However they compromised on religion. My mother explains that although her mother was a devout Methodist, George's leanings were toward non-belief and Unitarianism. They compromised on Congregationalism, in which my mother was raised, and in which she took no interest.

The other fact that I have been told about George Day Smith is that he liked to garden. Every summer he wore a new straw hat.

He died in 1946, thirteen years before I was born, at the age of 64.

 

Below: Entire Text from Deaths Page for G. Day Smith, Date Stamped Sep 11 1946

DEATHS

TRIBUTE TO G.DAY SMITH

Services Are Held for The Star's Assistant Sunday Editor

More than 100 persons attended funeral services yesterday afternoon for G. Day Smith, assistant Sunday editor of The Star, at the Stine and McClure chapel.

Dr. G. Charles Gray, pastor of the Westminster Congregational church who conducted the services, described Mr. Smith as a modest, quiet and thoughtful man.

"He was the first to disclaim the distinctions most men struggle after," Dr. Gray said. "He was devoid of those jealousies that sometimes mar human relationships. His was a modest but deep pride in the work he had chosen. he did his day's work as it came, with scrupulous respect for the task. He found a joy in the progress of his job, giving personal thought to the mechanics of run-of-the-mill tasks and encouragement to those with lesser experience than he whose work passed across his desk."


Below: Unsigned tribute to G. Day Smith from the Kansas City Star

G. Day Smith

"Over a period of more than twenty-five years associates of G. Day Smith in The Star's editorial rooms expected to find him at his desk just as naturally as they expected the daylight each morning. It seemed that he was always there and always earnestly engaged in his work. As The Star's assistant Sunday editor he was called upon to read an immense amount of copy and his constant interest was in correct writing. He edited articles with the utmost care but was always sympathetic in his criticisms - kindly, gentle and modest in manner as he was industrious in his labor."

"Mr. Smith's devotion to his work was matched fully by his devotion to his family and his home. It was a most congenial family life that drew the attention of friends and neighbors over a a long period of years. With her background of newspaper experiences Mrs. Smith followed closely the interest of her husband in The Star. With the two daughters the Smiths made up a happy family circle. The members had much in common in their education as in their love of the home and the gardening to which Mr. Smith gave much of his leisure time. The family grief at the death of Mr. Smith is mingled with the happiness of memories which are shared by the friends who knew him best"


Below: Primary obituary from the Kansas City Star

G. DAY SMITH IS DEAD

ILLNESS FATAL TO THE STAR ASSISTANT SUNDAY EDITOR

-----

Long Journalistic Career of "Whiz" Began as a Youth in Iowa - Had Been Operated on in March

G. Day Smith 64 years old, the Star's assistant Sunday editor, died yesterday afternoon after an illness of several months, part of which was spent at the Research hospital.

In the latter part of March Mr. Smith, because of failing health began a leave of absence from his work and entered the hospital for treatment. After three weeks in the hospital he returned to his home at 4915 Baltimore avenue, reentering the hospital only for periodical examinations. He was admitted to the hospital again Friday morning. His death at 2:55 yesterday afternoon was unexpected. His doctor gave the direct cause of death as uremic poisoning.

JOURNALISTIC INTEREST EARLY

Interest in journalism came early for Mr. Smith, known to his fellow workers as "Whiz" and he began preparations for his lifetime pursuit as a high school student at Eldora IA He was born at Mitchell SD His mother died when he was 2 years old and he was taken by relatives in Eldora to be reared.

English and foreign languages were his favored subjects in high school In 1902 Mr. Smith went to Central high school in Kansas City for a year's study to become eligible for admittance to Grinnell college. Grinnell, IA He ha completed the course at Eldora high school, but it was not sufficient for pre-enrollment requirements at the higher Iowa school.

He was a contributor to the school paper, the College Cyclone and an ardent follower of the Grinnell football teams. Friends on the The Star's sport desk remember his telephone calls from home to check on the results of the Grinnell games through many years.

PRIDE IN A DAUGHTER

This June his younger daughter Miss Georgianna Smith was graduated from his alma mater and it was with great pleasure that he attended the commencement exercises and the reunion of his class. Following his graduation from Grinnell, Mr. Smith was employed a year by the Des Moines Register before he accepted a position on the old Kansas City Post. From the Post he moved to the Hannibal Mo. Courier-Post. where he met a fellow reporter, Miss Bertha Schmidt, who later became his wife.

In 1912 he left the Courier-Post and was employed for the time by the Star. He remained with the Star several years, then was hired by the associated press and worked for the wire service in Chicago and Jefferson City.

MARRIES IN JUNE 1920

He returned to The Star in 1920 and began his career on the Sunday desk. He married Miss Schmidt June 19, 1920 and they came together to Kansas City where they have lived all their married life.

"Whiz" Smith found his greatest delight in journalism in the careful editing of copy. He preferred to sit quietly editing rephrasing smoothing and searching for the precise words to make the stories he was to present to the reader as concise as possible.

Gentle and soft-spoken Mr. Smith never raised his voice as he subtly suggested to reporters revisions in their copy which would improve a story.

He leaves his wife and the daughter Miss Georgianna Smith both of the home; another daughter Mrs. W.I. Longstreth and two grandchildren Wallace I. Longstreth III and Janice Longstreth, all of Washington D.C.

 

Mrs. N. Schwartz did some great research on G. Day Smith's adoptive parents, Marrium and John, for which I'm very grateful. Here's part what she found.

February 15, 2007

I know that on your website (which by the way is very nice) you wanted to know if anyone knew anything about Mariam Stevens and John Porter.

Well, what I managed to figure out by census records was that George Day Smith's grandparents were George Willard Day and Marilla Clark (I know you know that), but did you know that they had 2 Stevens men living with them in the 1860 Trumball, Ohio Census?

The 2 were Thomas Stevens, age 25 and Elijah Stevens age 22. It just so happens that if you go back one more census (1850), you will see that Willard and Marilla had other Stevens children living with them and they were: Stoddard Stevens, 19, OH., Miriam (this is Aunt Me), 15, OH., Elijah, 13, OH., Marilla, 10., OH., and Laura, 7, OH.. They also had an Abner Clark, age 40 living with them. I assume this was probably her brother, but not sure.

If I had to guess what the connection was, I would guess that Mariam's (Aunt Me) mother was Marilla Clark's sister, this is just my best guess. After doing research on my own family for over 15 years you get pretty good at connecting the dots. I base that guess on the fact that Miriam had a sister Marilla so it would be quite a coincidence that they were being raised by a woman with the name Marilla also. Therefore I believe that this was their Aunt and Uncle but of course the 1850 and 1860 census records don't ask what the relationship to the head of house hold is. Oh well, if you don't already have this information it's something to think about. Hopefully I haven't confused you.

--

Mariam and John Porter had only one child and it was a son. He was born in 1856 either January or June (I could not make out the census records). He followed in his fathers footsteps and studied law and became an attorney.

He married a woman by the name of Ellenore, born April 1863, Iowa to Edwin R. Bowe, born 1822, Ohio and Ann Jannett or Jannett Ann, born 1837 NY.

William and Ellenore had one child that I could find and her name was Hortense, born October 1886, Iowa. Based on Toledo, Tama, Iowa census records of 1870 Ellenore's (her name was spelled several ways) sister was also named Hortense (Hortense R) and she was born 1854, Ohio.

In 1900 Census records for Eldora, Iowa, William and family are living in close proximity to his mother and father. Also living with them are Ellenore's father Edwin R. Bowe, born August 1822, OH. he is widowed.

Couple of searching tips: I've see Mariam referred to as Mirium and Marilyn and some of the names that I gave you were exactly as found in the census records but they were notoriously wrong so don't go by that. I have Mariam listed as being born November 1835. OH.

 

Below: Judge John Porter and Miriam Stevens Porter, the adoptive parents of G. Day Smith, in an article noting their 50th wedding anniversary, in about the same year when G.Day Smith would have entered Grinnell College.

Back